Nineteen Eighty-Four:
A Horror of Truth
As a final
impendence to combat the thinking minds existing in Nineteen
Eighty-Four, the
ministry of love is assigned the task of brainwashing
exposed thought criminals. The violent procedure consists
of rounds of torture followed by simple questions. The
eventual goal of the process it to replace the subject’s
knowledge of oppression with ignorance to the point that
he cannot combine two and two to make four. Essentially,
the process is a means of re teaching the rebellious
mind to feel helpless without the oppressor. Although
the persons who undergo the brainwashing process are
told they will be executed upon the perfection of their
mind, the viewer is never given any conformation of this.
More than likely, the process is a method of reinstating
the powerless mindsets required to keep an oppressed
people in slavery. Killing the subjects after ‘fixing’ them
would not only be a waste of effort, but could also severely
cut into the party’s workforce. Instead, the use
of horror against the individual is a final way of convincing
the free mind that they are to remain fully reliant on
their oppressor, or suffer terrifying consequences.
The purpose behind marinating a helpless
mindset in the masses of Oceania is clarified in Howard
Zinn’s A Peoples History of the United States.
Zinn comments on why, at the time, Africans were the
preferred subjects for a slave class: “Their helplessness
made enslavement easier. The Indians were on their own
land. The Whites were in their own European culture.
The blacks had been torn from their land and culture” (26).
By commenting on the lifestyles of the Whites and the
Indians, Zinn is pointing out that these groups both
knew how to be self reliant in their present settings.
The Africans however, did not know how to survive on
their own, and faced numerous communication barriers.
They therefore relied on their masters to keep them alive;
participating in their labors was less of an option,
and more a necessity to survive. Similar to the execution
of thought criminals in Nineteen Eighty-Four the
torturing of disobedient slaves served to remind rebellious
minds of the ease at which their oppressor could inflict
pain upon them.
In the already obedient mind,
an oppressor uses horror to maintain this dependent way
of thinking. The subjects are conditioned to fear everyone
except their protector. The overall goal of continually
horrifying the submissive mind is to produce and preserve
the thought ‘How
would I survive without my leader, I am helpless without
them’. Conversely, in the rebellious intellect, horror
is used as a means of making the individual feel helpless
in the face of the oppressor, producing the thought ‘They
are too powerful, I am helpless to stop them’. As
was the case with Winston, this Horror is therefore used
by oppressors in two different manners to obtain the same
result, a helpless state of mind. Natural instinct will
drive an organism to do whatever it considers necessary
to survive. An individual that does not know how to survive
on their own will do what they are told if these actions
permit their continued existence. Freighting the individual
into feeling helpless as an individual will make them dependant,
and more importantly make them obedient.
Page 3 of 3
|